Skip to main content
General

Whatโ€™s Your Secret Ingredient?

By October 28, 2011October 2nd, 2013107 Comments

I love the idea of a recipe having a secret ingredient. When the girls were little, I would steal away to the corner of the kitchen to add a secret ingredient (sugar) to my magic hiccup potion (water). My friend Andras puts a shot of bourbon in his scrambled eggs. My old co-worker Myles adds a spoonful of peanut butter to his chili. (Maybe, using that trick, Andy wouldโ€™ve taken home a blue ribbon in theย chili off?) Andyโ€™s dad used to make burgers on the grill (a recipe that has come to be known as โ€œThe Dadoo Specialโ€) and weโ€™re still trying to figure out what the heck he put in those patties. But Iโ€™m curious: Whatโ€™s your secret ingredient? What have I not been adding to my spaghetti sauces, stews, soups, chilis, eggs, pies, omelets, cakes, quesadillas, mashed potatoes, beans, roast chickens, that I should have been adding all along?

107 Comments

  • Christine says:

    Jack Daniels to my Diet Coke. ๐Ÿ™‚ But really, we eat a lot of black beans , and in addition to the cumin, onion, and garlic I sautee before adding the beans, Iโ€™ve started adding a couple glugs of orange juice. Really brightens up the flavors without the astringency of lemon or lime.

    I love nutmeg with roasted cauliflower and carrots. Also love the idea of a little garam marsala in baked apple desserts!

  • Madie says:

    Adding to the list of foods that Worcestershire sauce improves: guacamole. Just two or three dashes. Really adds a certain smokey earthy umami-ness that makes everyone freak over your guac. ๐Ÿ™‚

  • Avatar Juliana says:

    For some reason this post (and the comments) reminds me of the childrenโ€™s book Thunder Cake by Patricia Polacco. For years after my much-younger sister got that book, our chocolate cakes had to include tomatoes.

  • Avatar Carolyn says:

    What a fascinating topic, thanks for โ€œputting it on the tableโ€! I add a drizzle of molasses to my finished homemade pasta sauce, and for scrambled eggs I include 2 additional ingredients: finely diced onion to the melted butter before pouring in the egg mixture โ€“ to which Iโ€™ve added dried basil.

  • Avatar klynnnn says:

    Great postโ€ฆ loved all the comments. My secret ingredients: a bit of cinnamon in the ricotta cheese mixture (which also includes eggs) for lasagna or stuffed shells, a TSP of grape jelly in spaghetti sauce to cut the acidity and a can of crab meat in spaghetti sauce to make plain spaghetti all that more yummy

  • angela@momsinthecity says:

    we like saying that our secret ingredient is always the same: LOVE. When I cook with my little daughters we send a kiss to the skillet or oven with our love. The recipe will taste much much better!!!

  • Avatar Annemarie Frost says:

    finely grated carrot inโ€ฆwell, a lot of things: meatloaf, meatballs, pasta sauce, homemade salsa, Spanish rice, etc.
    It adds a touch of sweetness and some nice health benefits!

Leave a Reply

What is 12 + 6 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:
IMPORTANT! To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math (so we know that you are a human) :-)