Skip to main content
Birthdays, Holidays, CelebrationsThanksgiving

The Only Thanksgiving Guide You Need

By November 5, 2013November 12th, 2013814 Comments

Last year, we devoted a lot of blog space to Thanksgiving, by Sam Sifton. And since weโ€™re editors and writers, supposedly on the pulse of what the lastest, greatest, trendiest everything is, we should probably be featuring this yearโ€™s of-the-moment holiday cookbook. But hereโ€™s the thing: โ€œtrendyโ€ and โ€œof-the-momentโ€ are not words that should EVER EVER EVER be in the same sentence as โ€œThanksgiving,โ€ and we stand by our claim that Sam Siftonโ€™s timeless, authoritative, delicious guide to our countryโ€™s greatest holiday is The Only Thanksgiving Recipe Collection You Will Ever Need. (Outside of your grandmotherโ€™s recipe box, of course โ€” we donโ€™t want to get anyone in trouble here). As such, we launch our โ€œCountdown to Thanksgiving Seriesโ€ with a bountiful giveaway: In the next 48 hours, five readers are eligible to win a free copy of Siftonโ€™s Thanksgiving, and five more are eligible to have a free copy sent to whoever is cooking/hosting the feastโ€ฆ as a little pre-holiday pump-up and thank-you-in-advance. Thatโ€™s TEN COPIES WE ARE GIVING AWAY. All you have to do is leave a comment below (we wouldnโ€™t complain if this comment included a Thanksgiving tip) and tell me which one you are: #Host or #Guest.

Update: All winners have been notified. Congrats Josh, Betsy, Candice, Eva, Molly, Susan, Colleen F, L, Divya, Memegirl and to everyone else thanks for playing!

Related: Sam Siftonโ€™s 1o Laws of Thanksgiving.

814 Comments

  • Avatar kathy says:

    AAAAANDโ€ฆ.it was even all Gluten Free. Everything. First time I didnโ€™t feel like a beached whale after a huge dinner like that. The best part was the stuffing. I used a half a pkg of gluten free ceasar salad croutons. Six slices of some weird flax seed bread thing I found in the freezer, cubed it and threw it in the toaster oven to crouton up. And about a cup of leftover cooked quinoa that I found in the fridge while hunting for the eggs. Added the usual stuff and threw in some toasted filberts I fished out of the freezer. Best stuffing ever. When I added some lea and perrins gluten free knock-off. The lid kinda popped off as I was adding a couple splashes and I ended up pouring waaaaay to much in. I thought for sure the stuffing was a goner. But did I mention that it was the best everโ€ฆ..

  • Avatar Tiffany says:

    I am a guest this year. Always clean up as you go along. Saves so much time and then you can enjoy the meal without worrying about all the clean up

  • Avatar Meagan B. says:

    We are usually #guests but bring a lot of dishes. When it comes to Thanksgiving, I am all about sticking to classic recipes and eating as much of them as possible.

  • Avatar Frances says:

    This year will be my first year spending Thanksgiving away from my family. Instead, I will be flying to San Diego to spend it with my fiancรฉ (!) and will be cooking my third Thanksgiving turkey in a grad dorm. Wish me luck!

  • Avatar TaraO says:

    My only tip is to plan ahead. . . Thanksgiving is not the kind of meal that you can just โ€œwing itโ€ and hope for the best! cteeobrien(at)cox{dot}net

  • Avatar Vanessa says:

    Iโ€™m the #host! Itโ€™s my first time and Iโ€™m having my whole family over. Eek! Did I mention I really just started cooking this year? Wish me luck

  • Avatar sf11 says:

    Iโ€™m a guest.

  • Avatar Rita says:

    I am a guest at my momโ€™s, I think this year we will bring a pumpkin stuffed with everything good: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=130704456

  • Avatar tenely says:

    I am host, serving 11 this year. We brine then grill our turkey. So delicious and it frees the oven for rolls and stuffing.

  • Avatar Caroline says:

    Guest this year, host last year. Made some amazing sweet potato biscuits last year that I will bring this year. Oh, and canโ€™t go wrong with a chocolate pecan pie.

  • Avatar Dawn says:

    We are hosting a big gathering this year. I suggest preparing as much as you can before thanksgiving day. We even get the turkey ready the night before (no stuffing in the cavity). Canโ€™t wait!!

  • Avatar Samantha H says:

    Iโ€™m a guest at my parentsโ€™ thanksgiving, but always go the night before to help with prep. This is pretty obvious, but preparing everything thatโ€™s possible to prepare the night before, and having all hands on deck to do so so youโ€™re not up until 1am, is my tip. Also, setting out the serving dishes the night before that youโ€™ll use speeds the process of getting food on the table the next day!

  • Avatar Annette says:

    #Hostโ€ฆ.and a first-timer to boot.
    It seemed like such a good idea when I offeredโ€ฆ..

  • Avatar Katy says:

    My mom and I are hosting for Thanksgiving this year! She stuffs our turkey with apples and pomegranates and bastes it with orange juice. It is seriously delicious every year. I am in charge of sides and have a weakness for gratins.

  • Avatar Angie Thomas says:

    I am hostโ€ฆjust as important as the food ( which will be wild turkey brined and roasted) is the atmosphere- I love to create one that feels welcoming, warm, simple, and beckoning. โ€ฆ to have real conversation and BE thankful!

  • Avatar Catherine says:

    #guest, I guessโ€ฆmy dadโ€™s cooking, but Iโ€™ll probably help out with some! All I can think about are brussels sprouts and mashed sweet potatoes!

  • Avatar Ting says:

    Iโ€™m the host! I became vegan this year and am hosting my first vegan Thanksgiving for a party of 12 in my 600 sq ft NYC apartment. I need all the help (and wine) I can get, so a copy of Same Siftonโ€™s book would be ah-mazing ๐Ÿ™‚

  • Avatar Shanti says:

    #guest, we have a newborn so I donโ€™t think too much cooking is happening at our house this yearโ€ฆbut we gotta have a pumpkin pie!

  • Avatar Abbie says:

    Host. Delegate! We always ask friends to bring their specialty dishes โ€“ and because we live far from family Thanksgiving is the one holiday we refuse to travel. Anyone is welcome to come to us, but we stay put!

  • Avatar Erika says:

    Hosting thanksgiving for the first time this year, so I donโ€™t have any tips yet. Wish me luck!

  • Aimee S. says:

    Iโ€™m the #host this year, as at six months pregnant I donโ€™t feel up to travelling! Make a detailed timeline working backwards from when you want to eat โ€“ and think realistically about how much time those small last-minute tasks will take! In worst-case scenarios, remember disasters make for great stories.

  • Avatar Susan says:

    Host. My main tip is to plan aheadโ€ฆ Iโ€™m nothing without a written time table and a really good plan. Good music and wine doesnโ€™t hurt either!

  • Avatar Shannon says:

    Host. My tip is to ask your company to bring a dish and the serving utensil to go with it.

  • Avatar Blair says:

    I the co-host with my sister. My tip would be to make it fun! Each year my sister and I get our families together the night before for a sleepover/prep thankgiving party. We usually order pizza and drink wine while doing anything we can to make the next day easier. The kiddos (ranging in age from 21-2) are in charge of setting the table, peeling potatoes etc.

  • Avatar Starlene says:

    Make lists, delegate and prep in advance.

Leave a Reply

What is 2 + 9 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:
IMPORTANT! To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math (so we know that you are a human) :-)